Purdue University 1999 Swine Day Report

Effects of Corn and Conjugated Linoleic Acid (CLA) on the Storage and Shelf Life of Fresh Pork

C.A. Stahl, J.M. Eggert, B.T. Richert, D.E.Gerrard, J.C. Forrest, B.C. Bowker, E.J. Wynveen, J.E. Hammelman, and A.P. Schinckel
Department of Animal Sciences

Introduction

Conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) has been demonstrated to have anticarcinogenic effects in a number of laboratory tests. Such effects have been attributed to the antioxidant properties of CLA. Because the quality of fresh pork is affected by oxidation, the purpose of this trial was to determine whether CLA, as a component of pork, would enhance the storage and shelf life of fresh pork.

Materials and Methods

Gilts (n=78) were fed one of four diets containing either Optimum® high oleic, high oil corn (HOHOC), conventional corn (CONV), high oil corn (HOC), or conventional corn supplemented with choice white grease (CWG) on an ad libitum basis beginning at 55 lb live weight. Additionally, diets were supplemented with either 1% CLA oil (60% CLA) or 1% sunflower oil (SFO) from 200 lb until slaughter at 258 lb.

At 24 hours postmortem, both the left and right side loins (6th-10th ribs) were removed and evaluated for color by three trained graduate students using established NPPC guidelines (1=pale, pinkish gray; 5=dark red, purple), as well as with the use of a Hunter Colorimeter (L*, a*, b*). The numbers given by the Hunter machine represent an average lightness vs. darkness of the loin for three distinct color spectrums (L*: 100=white, 0=black; a*: 100=red, -100=green; b*: 100=yellow, -100= blue). Loins were then weighed, vacuum packaged and placed in frozen storage for a duration of either 14 or 35 days. Upon completion of the frozen storage, each loin was removed and allowed to thaw at 35.5°F for 36 hours in the cooler. Loins were weighed and cut into five separate chops approximately .75 inch in thickness. The two external chops were discarded. The three internal chops were randomly assigned to a 1, 3 or 5 day shelf life duration, weighed, and reevaluated for color. Individual chops were presented on styrofoam, sealed with plastic wrap, and displayed under constant fluorescent light. Upon reaching the assigned shelf life duration, chops were again weighed and evaluated for color.

Results

At 24 hours postmortem, the subjective color evaluations of the loins were significantly affected by corn (HOHOC: 2.33; CONV: 2.51; HOC: 2.29; CWG: 2.28; P<.05). These effects, however, were not detected by the Hunter L*, a*, or b* values (Table 1). Color was subjectively evaluated to have improved during frozen storage for both HOC and CWG-fed pigs, but these results were not confirmed by objective measures with the Hunter Colorimeter. After being displayed for 5 days, corn had a significant effect on a* values (HOHOC: 10.69; CONV: 9.56; HOC: 10.12; CWG: 10.28, P<.05).

Chops from gilts fed CLA received higher subjective color evaluations than control gilts at 24 hours postmortem, and improved color after being displayed for three days based on the change from day 1 to day 3 (Table 2). However, these differences were minor and not confirmed by objective measures of color. At 24 hours postmortem, the L* values were slightly lower for CLA treated loins and a* values were higher (10.18 vs 9.56, P<.19). This shows evidence that the Hunter scores follow the same pattern, and give support to the visual scores, although they are not statistically significant. These differences may have occurred because score evaluators were focusing on the combination of overall redness and slightly increased darkness of the CLA treated loins. Following frozen storage, CLA had a negative effect on color scores, but a* values were significantly lower in the chops of CLA-fed pigs.

At day 5 of shelf life, the loin chops frozen for 14 days received significantly higher color evaluations (2.45 vs. 2.34, P<.01), lower L* values (59.8 vs. 61.2, P<.01), higher a* values (10.9 vs. 9.4, P<.01), and lower b* values (16.8 vs. 17.6, P<.01) than loins frozen for 35 days (Table 3).

Implications

Both corn type and CLA have minimal effects on the color characteristics of frozen and displayed loin chops. Thus, the feeding of CLA to enhance pig growth, carcass composition, and fresh pork quality (described elsewhere) does not raise any storage or shelf life concerns.


Table 1. Effect of corn type on storage and shelf life.

Trait

CWG

CONV

HOHOC

HOC

SE

Signif.

24 hours postmortem

Color

2.28

2.51

2.33

2.29

.06

.0128

L*

59.10

57.43

59.73

57.83

.80

.1233

a*

9.66

9.99

9.99

9.85

.50

.9634

b*

13.81

13.49

13.23

13.37

.24

.4687

Effect of storage

Purge

5.36

5.36

6.16

5.69

.30

.1957

Color

.12

-.002

.001

.16

.05

.0493

L*

.20

-.007

-.43

.92

.65

.4480

a*

1.59

.83

.29

.87

.48

.4002

b*

1.27

1.30

2.02

1.55

.31

.3240

Day 1 shelf

Color

2.43

2.45

2.42

2.44

.05

.9758

L*

59.07

59.15

58.61

58.66

.41

.7072

a*

10.96

11.50

10.91

10.51

.56

.6487

b*

15.16

15.25

15.09

14.85

.16

.2966

Day 3 shelf

Color

2.44

2.43

2.49

2.50

.05

.6466

L*

60.90

60.25

60.35

60.15

.40

.5615

a*

11.20

11.06

11.33

11.32

.28

.8907

b*

17.70

17.62

17.68

17.43

.14

.4386

Day 5 shelf

Color

2.38

2.38

2.39

2.43

.04

.8561

L*

60.67

60.59

59.94

60.73

.40

.4659

a*

10.28

9.56

10.69

10.12

.26

.0262

b*

17.41

17.16

17.16

16.98

.13

.1563

Change during shelf display day 3-1

Color

.01

-.02

.07

.05

.04

.3241

L*

1.83

1.10

1.71

1.64

.26

.2066

a*

.26

-.45

.47

.76

.66

.5957

b*

2.53

2.40

2.62

2.59

.19

.8424

Change in shelf display days 5-1

Color

-.05

-.07

-.03

-.02

.04

.8549

L*

1.60

1.44

1.33

2.07

.34

.4211

a*

-.68

-1.95

-.22

-.39

.64

.2198

b*

2.20

1.95

2.08

2.11

.18

.8081

 

Table 2. Effect of CLA on shelf and storage life.

Trait

CLA

No CLA

SE

Signif.

24 hours postmortem

Color

2.44

2.27

.04

.0035

L*

58.23

58.79

.60

.4945

a*

10.18

9.56

.30

.1854

b*

13.39

13.56

.17

.4781

Effect of Storage

Purge

5.70

5.60

.21

.7086

Color

-.06

.20

.04

.0001

L*

.59

-.25

.46

.2079

a*

.25

1.55

.34

.0093

b*

1.52

1.55

.22

.9430

Day 1 shelf

Color

2.41

2.47

.04

.2586

L*

58.91

58.83

.29

.8338

a*

10.79

11.15

.40

.5144

b*

15.05

15.13

.10

.6290

Day 3 shelf

Color

2.47

2.45

.03

.6639

L*

60.53

60.30

.28

.5683

a*

11.26

11.21

.20

.8355

b*

17.63

17.59

.10

.7566

Day 5 shelf

Color

2.40

2.39

.03

.8148

L*

60.63

60.35

.28

.4565

a*

10.12

10.20

.19

.7615

b*

17.16

17.20

.09

.7772

Change during shelf display 3-1

Color

.07

-.01

.03

.0313

L*

1.67

1.47

.19

.4434

a*

.47

.05

.47

.5228

b*

2.61

2.47

.13

.4621

Change during shelf display 5-1

Color

-.006

-.08

.03

.0726

L*

1.71

1.51

.24

.5446

a*

-.66

-.95

.50

.6562

b*

2.10

2.07

.13

.8497

 

Table 3. Effect of duration of freezing on color scores.

Trait

Day 14

Day 35

SE

Signif.

Day 1 shelf - Color

2.51

2.36

.04

.0051

Day 1 shelf - L*

58.43

59.32

.28

.0303

Day 1 shelf - a*

10.34

11.60

.40

.0258

Day 1 shelf - b*

15.01

15.17

.10

.3067

 

 

 

 

 

Day 5 shelf - Color

2.45

2.34

.03

.0080

Day 5 shelf - L*

59.81

61.16

.28

.0007

Day 5 shelf - a*

10.91

9.42

.19

.0001

Day 5 shelf - b*

16.77

17.58

.09

.0001


Index of 1999 Purdue Swine Day Articles

If you have trouble accessing this page because of a disability, please email anscweb@purdue.edu.